Autoinfarction of a parathyroid adenoma can have an atypical clinicoradiologic features that can mimic an inflammatory process or malignancy. In addition, the associated fibrosis makes surgical resection more challenging than for regular parathyroid adenomas. The implications of these findings are that while autoinfarction of parathyroid adenomas is a rare phenomenon, this entity should be considered when there are heterogeneous and cystic components on imaging in patients without hypercalcemia. Ultimately, histopathology is necessary for definitive diagnosis.