Dust abraded from thiamethoxam-treated seed during sowing: Refining the risk assessment for native bees in Brazil.
Helen M ThompsonAna CioneMario PanagioMariana ArtalJosé S VeigaAdhemar OliveiraVinícius MarecaPublished in: Integrated environmental assessment and management (2023)
During sowing using pneumatic machinery, dust may be abraded from pesticide-treated seed and contaminate adjacent bee-attractive off-crop areas. This study quantified the risk to native bees of dust released during sowing of Brazilian crop seeds treated with a thiamethoxam formulation (Cruiser 350FS). To address toxicity to native bees, adult acute contact LD50 data for thiamethoxam were collated from the literature, a species sensitivity distribution generated, and the HD 5 calculated. The LD50 HD 5 was used to refine the default safety factor applied to the honeybee acute contact LD50 from 10 to 5.45 for thiamethoxam. Crop-specific abraded dust data (Heubach dust and Heubach AI) were generated for seeds treated with Cruiser 350FS sourced from on-farm and industrial facilities. The mean Heubach dust levels was ranked as cotton = maize > sunflower = soybean > drybean. There was no correlation between the measured residues of thiamethoxam (Heubach AI) and those estimated in dust based on the thiamethoxam content of Cruiser 350FS. A hazard quotient (HQ) for each crop (based on application rate, the default dust deposition factor, and the honeybee contact LD50/10) identified risks during sowing for all crops. Refinement of the application rate with the measured 90th percentile Heubach dust (assuming 100% thiamethoxam) resulted in sowing of industrially treated soybean and on-farm treated cotton being identified as risks. Further refinement using either the measured 90th percentile Heubach AI or the acute contact LD50 (HD 5 ) resulted in sowing of all crops treated with Cruiser 350FS as being identified as low risk. Similar high quality seed treatment should be demonstrated for other formulations containing insecticides with high toxicity to bees. Data on dust drift from machinery and crops more representative of those in Brazil may allow further refinement of the default dust deposition value of 17% used in this study. Integr Environ Assess Manag 2023;00:1-13. © 2023 SETAC.
Keyphrases
- human health
- risk assessment
- health risk assessment
- health risk
- polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons
- climate change
- heavy metals
- liver failure
- drinking water
- oxidative stress
- functional connectivity
- systematic review
- intensive care unit
- big data
- respiratory failure
- machine learning
- aortic dissection
- combination therapy
- young adults
- deep learning
- acute respiratory distress syndrome
- hepatitis b virus