Pleistocene sea level changes and crocodile population histories on the Isthmus of Panama: A comment on Avila-Cervantes et al. (2020).

Avila-Cervantes et al. proposed that glacial-interglacial sea level changes played an important role in the evolutionary and demographic histories of the crocodile Crocodylus acutus on the Isthmus of Panama. However, the study used erroneous sea level proxy data that produced flawed paleogeographic reconstructions. We present new paleogeographic reconstructions and review the timing of, and proposed mechanisms behind, the demographic events estimated by Avila-Cervantes et al.. With the data currently available, we find little evidence to support the hypothesis that sea level changes drove population demographic events in crocodiles on the Isthmus. Alternative hypotheses, including changing climate and habitat suitability, are equally valid and should be considered along with well-supported sea level models.