Trust criteria for artificial intelligence in health: normative and epistemic considerations.
Kristin Marie Kostick-QuenetBenjamin H LangJared SmithMeghan HurleyJennifer Blumenthal-BarbyPublished in: Journal of medical ethics (2023)
Rapid advancements in artificial intelligence and machine learning (AI/ML) in healthcare raise pressing questions about how much users should trust AI/ML systems, particularly for high stakes clinical decision-making. Ensuring that user trust is properly calibrated to a tool's computational capacities and limitations has both practical and ethical implications, given that overtrust or undertrust can influence over-reliance or under-reliance on algorithmic tools, with significant implications for patient safety and health outcomes. It is, thus, important to better understand how variability in trust criteria across stakeholders, settings, tools and use cases may influence approaches to using AI/ML tools in real settings. As part of a 5-year, multi-institutional Agency for Health Care Research and Quality-funded study, we identify trust criteria for a survival prediction algorithm intended to support clinical decision-making for left ventricular assist device therapy, using semistructured interviews (n=40) with patients and physicians, analysed via thematic analysis. Findings suggest that physicians and patients share similar empirical considerations for trust, which were primarily epistemic in nature, focused on accuracy and validity of AI/ML estimates. Trust evaluations considered the nature, integrity and relevance of training data rather than the computational nature of algorithms themselves, suggesting a need to distinguish 'source' from 'functional' explainability. To a lesser extent, trust criteria were also relational (endorsement from others) and sometimes based on personal beliefs and experience. We discuss implications for promoting appropriate and responsible trust calibration for clinical decision-making use AI/ML.
Keyphrases
- artificial intelligence
- machine learning
- health information
- big data
- healthcare
- deep learning
- decision making
- patient safety
- end stage renal disease
- ejection fraction
- newly diagnosed
- primary care
- chronic kidney disease
- social media
- public health
- quality improvement
- left ventricular assist device
- stem cells
- peritoneal dialysis
- health insurance
- sensitive detection