Ethical dilemmas in prioritizing patients for scarce radiotherapy resources.
Rebecca J DeBoerAnita HoEspérance MutoniwaseCam NguyenGrace UmutesiJean Bosco BigirimanaNicaise NsabimanaKatherine Van LoonLawrence N ShulmanScott A TriedmanVincent K CubakaCyprien ShyiramberePublished in: BMC medical ethics (2024)
Multiple competing principles create tension with the agreed upon overarching goal of maximizing lives saved, including another utilitarian approach of maximizing life-years saved as well as non-utilitarian principles, such as egalitarianism, prioritarianism, and deontology. Clinical guidelines for patient prioritization for radiotherapy can combine multiple principles into a single allocation system to a significant extent. However, conflicting views about the role that social factors should play, and the dynamic nature of resource availability, highlight the need for ongoing work to evaluate and refine priority setting systems based on stakeholder views.