The Dog That Didn't Bark: A New Interpretation of Hypsoporphyrin Spectra and the Question of Hypsocorroles.

Nearly a half-century after Gouterman classified the UV-vis-NIR spectra of porphyrin derivatives as normal, hyper, or hypso, we propose a heretofore unsuspected "mechanism" underlying hypso spectra. Hypsoporphyrins, which exhibit blueshifted optical spectra relative to normal porphyrins (such as Zn porphyrins), typically involve dn transition metal ions, where n > 6. The spectral blueshifts have been traditionally ascribed to elevated porphyrin eg LUMO (lowest unoccupied molecular orbital) energy levels as a result of antibonding interactions with metal dπ orbitals. Herein, we have found instead that the blueshifts reflect a lowering of the a2u HOMO (highest occupied molecular orbital) energy levels. Electronegative metals such as Pd and Pt transfer smaller quantities of electron density to the porphyrin nitrogens, compared to a more electropositive metal such as Zn. With large amplitudes at the porphyrin nitrogens, the a2u HOMOs of Pd(II) and Pt(II) porphyrins accordingly exhibit lower orbital energies than those of Zn(II) porphyrins, thus explaining the hypso effect. Hypso spectra are also observed for corroles: compared with six-coordinate Al(III) corroles, which may be thought of exhibiting normal spectra, Au(III) corroles, for instance, exhibit blueshifted or hypso spectra.