Alkanes versus Oligosilanes: Conformational Effects on σ-Electron Delocalization.

Observations and computations both suggest that the extent and the conformational dependence of σ-electron delocalization in frontier molecular orbitals are quite different in alkanes C n H 2 n +2 and oligosilanes Si n H 2 n +2 , the isosteric and isoelectronic saturated chains built from carbon or silicon atoms, respectively. We find that the different conformational effects can be understood in simple intuitive terms. There are two modes of σ-electron delocalization, strongly conformation-sensitive skeletal delocalization through backbone X-X bonds (σ-conjugation and σ-hyperconjugation) and only weakly conformation-sensitive lateral delocalization through lateral X-H bonds (σ-hyperconjugation and σ-homoconjugation). In alkanes, both modes are active and complement each other, leading to delocalization in all conformations. In oligosilanes, only skeletal delocalization of holes is important in frontier orbitals, and the even simpler ladder C model provides an adequate intuitive description of the strong conformational dependence of σ-electron delocalization. Ultimately, the difference is primarily due to the similar electronegativity of carbon and hydrogen as opposed to the lower electronegativity of silicon, which causes a polarization of Si-H bonds. This understanding has been derived from an analysis of approximate algebraic solutions of a simple Hückel-level extended ladder H model for an infinite regular helical chain, using the effective mass of a hole as a measure of delocalization. This model is derived from the classical Sandorfy H model, and is parametrized by fitting to results of density functional or Hartree-Fock theory.