Elementary Reaction Steps That Precede or Follow a Unimolecular Reaction Step Can Obfuscate Interpretation of the Driving-Force Dependence to Its Rate Constant.

Assessing the validity of a driving-force-dependent kinetic theory for a unimolecular elementary reaction step is difficult when the observed reaction rate is strongly influenced by properties of the preceding or following elementary reaction step. A well-known example occurs for bimolecular reactions with weak orbital overlap, such as outer-sphere electron transfer, where bimolecular collisional encounters that precede a fast unimolecular electron-transfer step can limit the observed rate. A lesser-appreciated example occurs for bimolecular reactions with stronger orbital overlap, including many proton-transfer reactions, where equilibration of an endergonic unimolecular proton-transfer step results in a relatively small concentration of reaction products, thus slowing the rate of the following step such that it becomes rate limiting. Incomplete consideration of these points has led to discrepancies in interpretation of data from the literature. Our reanalysis of these data suggests that proton-transfer elementary reaction steps have a nonzero intrinsic free energy barrier, implying, in the parlance of Marcus theory, that there is non-negligible nuclear reorganization. Outcomes from our analyses are generalizable to inner-sphere electron-transfer reactions such as those involved in (photo)electrochemical fuel-forming reactions.