Background: Cutaneous mastocytosis (CM) occurs when abnormal mast cells accumulate in the skin, whereas in systemic mastocytosis (SM), accumulation also occurs in other tissues. A transition from CM to SM is an atypical occurrence in pediatric patients. Case Presentation: An 8-month-old female presented with a 3-month history of whole body hyperpigmented macules with a normal serum tryptase level, consistent with a diagnosis of CM. At age 2.5 years, cutaneous lesions increased and repeat serum tryptase levels were elevated. Subsequent positive peripheral blood KIT D816V mutation testing furthered concern for a monoclonal mast cell disorder; therefore, prompting a bone marrow biopsy which was consistent with a diagnosis of SM. Conclusion: Our case depicts the possible transition from CM to SM in a pediatric patient. Despite an initial presentation consistent with a diagnosis of CM, watchful monitoring for signs and symptoms indicative of systemic involvement may be warranted in some pediatric patients.