SARS-CoV-2 rapid antigen test in comparison to RT-PCR targeting different genes: A real-life evaluation among unselected patients in a regional hospital of Italy.
Davide TreggiariChiara PiubelliSara CaldrerManuela MistrettaAndrea RagusaPierantonio OrzaBarbara PajolaDonatella PiccoliAntonio ContiCarlo LorenziValentina SerafiniMarco BoniFrancesca PerandinPublished in: Journal of medical virology (2021)
We assessed the performance of the Panbio rapid antigen detection (RAD) test for the detection of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) infection and we compared it with the routine reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR)-based molecular test in a population of 4167 unselected patients admitted to IRCCS Sacro Cuore Don Calabria Hospital. Analysis stratified by cycling threshold (Ct ) value of SARS-CoV-2 gene targets indicated that antigen (Ag)-positive Ct values were significantly lower compared to Ag-negative values (p < 0.0001). Overall, we found discordance in 140, tested negative by RAD and positive by RT-PCR, and in 4 resulted positive by RAD and negative by RT-PCR. RAD test achieved a sensitivity and specificity of 66.82% and 99.89%, respectively. The positive predictive value was shown to be 97.87% while the negative predictive value was shown to be 97.62%. In our context, the RAD test showed a reliable diagnostic response in subjects that displayed high Ct values, corresponding to high viral load, while low ability was displayed to identify positive cases with medium-low Ct values, thus presenting low viral load and where confirmatory RT-PCR was needed. Our finding supports the use of the RAD test in real-life settings where a high volume of swabs is being processed but with caution when interpreting a positive test result in a low prevalence setting.
Keyphrases
- sars cov
- respiratory syndrome coronavirus
- dna damage
- dna repair
- real time pcr
- computed tomography
- image quality
- dual energy
- healthcare
- loop mediated isothermal amplification
- contrast enhanced
- genome wide
- quantum dots
- emergency department
- drug delivery
- positron emission tomography
- high intensity
- copy number
- single molecule
- bioinformatics analysis