The glenohumeral joint is the least congruent and least constrained joint with a complex relationship of static and dynamic stabilizers to balance its native mobility with functional stability. In the young athlete, anterior shoulder instability is multifactorial and can be a challenge to treat, requiring a patient-specific treatment approach. Surgical decision-making must consider patient-specific factors such as age, sport activity and level, underlying ligamentous laxity, and goals for return to activity, in addition to careful scrutiny of the underlying pathology to include humeral and glenoid bone loss and surrounding scapular bone morphology.