Structure-Photoreactivity Studies of BODIPY Photocages: Limitations of the Activation Barrier for Optimizing Photoreactions.

BODIPY photocages are photoreactive chromophores that release covalently linked cargo upon absorption of visible light. Here, we used computations of the T 1 photoheterolysis barrier to ascertain whether a computational approach could assist in a priori structure design by identifying new structures with higher quantum yields of photorelease. The electronic structure-photoreactivity relationships were elucidated for boron-substituted and core-functionalized 2-substituted BODIPY photocages as well as aryl substitutions at the meso -methyl position. Although there is a clear trend for the 2-substituted derivatives, with donor-substituted derivatives featuring both lower computed barriers and higher experimental quantum yields, no trend in the quantum yield with the computed activation barrier is found for the meso -methyl-substituted or boron-substituted derivatives. The lack of a correlation between the experimental quantum yield with the computed barrier in the latter two substitution cases is attributed to the substituents having larger effects on the rates of competing channels (internal conversion and competitive photoreactions) than on the rate of the photoheterolysis channel. Thus, although in some cases computed photoreaction barriers can aid in identifying structures with higher quantum yields, the ignored impacts of how changing the structure affects the rates of competing photophysical/photochemical channels limit the effectiveness of this single-parameter approach.