Diverse origins of near-identical antifreeze proteins in unrelated fish lineages provide insights into evolutionary mechanisms of new gene birth and protein sequence convergence.

Determining the origins of novel genes and the genetic mechanisms underlying the emergence of new functions is challenging yet crucial for understanding evolutionary innovations. The convergently evolved fish antifreeze proteins provide excellent opportunities to investigate evolutionary origins and pathways of new genes. Particularly notable is the near-identical type I antifreeze proteins (AFPI) in four phylogenetically divergent fish taxa. This study tested the hypothesis of protein sequence convergence beyond functional convergence in three unrelated AFPI-bearing fish lineages, revealing different paths by which a similar protein arose from diverse genomic resources. Comprehensive comparative analyses of de novo sequenced genome of the winter flounder and grubby sculpin, available high-quality genome of the cunner and 14 other relevant species found that the near-identical AFPI originated from a distinct genetic precursor in each lineage. Each independently evolved a coding region for the novel ice-binding protein while retaining sequence identity in the regulatory regions with their respective ancestor. The deduced evolutionary processes and molecular mechanisms are consistent with the Innovation-Amplification-Divergence (IAD) model applicable to AFPI formation in all three lineages, a new Duplication-Degeneration-Divergence (DDD) model we propose for the sculpin lineage, and a DDD model with gene fission for the cunner lineage. This investigation illustrates the multiple ways by which a novel functional gene with sequence convergence at the protein level could evolve across divergent species, advancing our understanding of the mechanistic intricacies in new gene formation.