Reply to the 'Comment on "Bilayer aggregate microstructure determines viscoelasticity of lung surfactant suspensions"' by J.-F. Berret, DOI: 10.1039/d2sm00653g.

In their comment, Berret suggests that Curosurf, one of three clinical lung surfactant aqueous suspensions examined in the Soft Matter , 2021, 17 , 5170-51820 is a Newtonian liquid rather than a shear-thinning soft solid with a small, but measurable yield stress. We postulate that these discrepancies may be due to the size of the magnetic wire measurement probe used in their paper (Thai et al. , Colloids Surf., B , 2019, 178 , 337-345) the diameter of which is similar in size to the Curosurf bilayer agregates (1-10 μm). The cone and plate rheometer used by Ciutara and Zasadzinski measures averaged effects over the entire macroscopic sample. Our combined results point out that the local viscoelastic properties of a moderately dense suspension may be different than its bulk properties.