In the age of increasing transparency, dermatologists may encounter requests from patients to alter or withhold key medical information from their electronic medical records. Per the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, patients have the right to view their medical record and request amendments; however, the physician is the final decision maker on what information should be included in the chart. It is integral that medically necessary information is included in the chart in accordance with the principle of beneficence and nonmaleficence. Withholding medically pertinent history may cause harm to the patient. Navigating such challenging situations while maintaining transparency requires a thorough understanding of the patient's dilemma. This contribution provides a framework by applying multiple ethical principles and will empower dermatologists to navigate such requests.