Dollar spot, a highly destructive turfgrasses disease worldwide, is caused by multiple species within the genus Clarireedia. Previous research indicated varying sensitivity to boscalid among Clarireedia populations not historically exposed to succinate dehydrogenase inhibitors (SDHIs). This study confirms that the differential sensitivity pattern is inherent among different Clarireedia spp., utilizing a combination of phylogenetic analyses, in vitro cross-resistance assays, and genetic transformation of target genes with different mutations. Furthermore, greenhouse inoculation experiments revealed that the differential boscalid sensitivity did not lead to pathogenicity issues or fitness penalties, thereby not resulting in control failure by boscalid. This research underscores the importance of continuous monitoring of fungicide sensitivity trends and highlights the complexity of chemical control of dollar spot due to the inherent variability in fungicide sensitivity among different Clarireedia spp.