Login / Signup

The impact of developmental language disorder in a defendant's description on mock jurors' perceptions and judgements.

Hannah Madaleine HobsonJemma WoodleySamantha GamblenJoanna BrackelyFiona O'NeillDanielle MilesClaire Westwood
Published in: International journal of language & communication disorders (2022)
What is already known on the subject There is already evidence that some conditions that affect communication, specifically autism, also affect juror perceptions. Research also shows that knowing whether or not a defendant has autism influences how jurors rate defendants. However, autism is not the only condition that is relevant to juror perceptions, as we also know that a high rate of young offenders have language needs, and many have language profiles like DLD. What this paper adds to existing knowledge There is little research on how behaviours associated with DLD impact others' perceptions. This study reports the impact of knowing about a defendant's DLD on juror perceptions, investigating whether knowing about DLD improves judgements on guilt, sentencing lengths, credibility and culpability. Beyond the content of youth offending, this study suggests behaviours associated with DLD lead people to form more negative judgements about youth with DLD. This is important because there is still a lack of awareness of DLD both in- and outside the criminal justice system. What are the potential or actual clinical implications of this work? This study shows that knowing about a person's DLD has largely positive effects on others' perceptions of them. This implies that recognizing undetected language needs in young offenders, and supporting colleagues and members of the public to know what DLD is and how it affects people, is critical for youth with DLD to be judged fairly. This study will support the case for raising awareness of vulnerability within the youth justice population, and will assist in clinicians evidencing the need for our roles in justice settings.
Keyphrases
  • healthcare
  • autism spectrum disorder
  • primary care
  • mental health
  • young adults
  • physical activity
  • intellectual disability
  • climate change
  • risk assessment
  • palliative care