Login / Signup

Which ethical values underpin England's National Health Service reset of paediatric and maternity services following COVID-19: a rapid review.

Anna ChiumentoPaul BainesCaroline RedheadSara FovargueHeather DraperLucy Frith
Published in: BMJ open (2021)
Our findings suggest that relationality is a prominent ethical principle informing resetting NHS non-COVID-19 paediatric surgery and maternity services. Sources explicitly highlight the ethical importance of seeking to minimise disruption to caring and dependent relationships, while simultaneously attending to public safety. Engagement with ethical principles was ethics-lite, with sources mentioning principles in passing rather than explicitly applying them. This leaves decision makers and healthcare professionals without an operationalisable ethical framework to apply to difficult reset decisions and risks inconsistencies in decision making. We recommend further research to confirm or refine the usefulness of the reset phase ethical framework developed through our analysis.
Keyphrases