Macrophages modulate mesenchymal stem cell function via tumor necrosis factor alpha in tooth extraction model.

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and macrophages collaboratively contribute to bone regeneration after injury. However, detailed mechanisms underlying the interaction between MSCs and inflammatory macrophages (M1) remain unclear. A macrophage-depleted tooth extraction model was generated in 5-wk-old female C57BL/6J mice using clodronate liposome (12.5 mg/kg/mouse, intraperitoneally) or saline injection (control) before maxillary first molar extraction. Mice were sacrificed on days 1, 3, 5, 7, and 10 after tooth extraction ( n  = 4). Regenerated bone volume evaluation of tooth extraction socket (TES) and histochemical analysis of CD80 + M1, CD206 + M2 (anti-inflammatory macrophages), PDGFRα + MSC, and TNF-α + cells were performed. In vitro, isolated MSCs with or without TNF-α stimulation (10 ng/mL, 24 h, n  = 3) were bulk RNA-sequenced (RNA-Seq) to identify TNF-α stimulation-specific MSC transcriptomes. Day 7 micro-CT and HE staining revealed significantly lower mean bone volume (clodronate vs control: 0.01 mm 3 vs 0.02 mm 3 , p <.0001) and mean percentage of regenerated bone area per total TES in clodronate group (41.97% vs 54.03%, p <.0001). Clodronate group showed significant reduction in mean number of CD80 + , TNF-α + , PDGFRα + , and CD80 + TNF-α + cells on day 5 (306.5 vs 558.8, p <.0001; 280.5 vs 543.8, p <.0001; 365.0 vs 633.0, p <.0001, 29.0 vs 42.5, p <.0001), while these cells recovered significantly on day 7 (493.3 vs 396.0, p =.0004; 479.3 vs 384.5, p =.0008; 593.0 vs 473.0, p =.0010, 41.0 vs 32.5, p =.0003). RNA-Seq analysis showed that 15 genes (|log2FC| > 5.0, log2TPM > 5) after TNF-α stimulation were candidates for regulating MSC's immunomodulatory capacity. In vivo, Clec4e and Gbp6 are involved in inflammation and bone formation. Clec4e , Gbp6 , and Cxcl10 knockdown increased osteogenic differentiation of MSCs in vitro. Temporal reduction followed by apparent recovery of TNF-α-producing M1 macrophages and MSCs after temporal macrophage depletion suggests that TNF-α activated MSCs during TES healing. In vitro mimicking the effect of TNF-α on MSCs indicated that there are 15 candidate MSC genes for regulation of immunomodulatory capacity.