Diversity in Biological Function and Mechanism of the tRNA Methyltransferase Trm10.

ConspectusTransfer ribonucleic acid (tRNA) is the most highly modified RNA species in the cell, and loss of tRNA modifications can lead to growth defects in yeast as well as metabolic, neurological, and mitochondrial disorders in humans. Significant progress has been made toward identifying the enzymes that are responsible for installing diverse modifications in tRNA, revealing a landscape of fascinating biological and mechanistic diversity that remains to be fully explored. Most early discoveries of tRNA modification enzymes were in model systems, where many enzymes were not strictly required for viability, an observation somewhat at odds with the extreme conservation of many of the same enzymes throughout multiple domains of life. Moreover, many tRNA modification enzymes act on more than one type of tRNA substrate, which is not necessarily surprising given the similar overall secondary and tertiary structures of tRNA, yet biochemical characterization has revealed interesting patterns of substrate specificity that can be challenging to rationalize on a molecular level. Questions about how many enzymes efficiently select a precise set of target tRNAs from among a structurally similar pool of molecules persist.The tRNA methyltransferase Trm10 provides an exciting paradigm to study the biological and mechanistic questions surrounding tRNA modifications. Even though the enzyme was originally characterized in Saccharomyces cerevisiae where its deletion causes no detectable phenotype under standard lab conditions, several more recently identified phenotypes provide insight into the requirement for this modification in the overall quality control of the tRNA pool. Studies of Trm10 in yeast also revealed another characteristic feature that has turned out to be a conserved feature of enzymes throughout the Trm10 family tree. We were initially surprised to see that purified S. cerevisiae Trm10 was capable of modifying tRNA substrates that were not detectably modified by the enzyme in vivo in yeast. This pattern has continued to emerge as we and others have studied Trm10 orthologs from Archaea and Eukarya, with enzymes exhibiting in vitro substrate specificities that can differ significantly from in vivo patterns of modification. While this feature complicates efforts to predict substrate specificities of Trm10 enzymes in the absence of appropriate genetic systems, it also provides an exciting opportunity for studying how enzyme activities can be regulated to achieve dynamic patterns of biological tRNA modification, which have been shown to be increasingly important for stress responses and human disease. Finally, the intriguing diversity in target nucleotide modification that has been revealed among Trm10 orthologs is distinctive among known tRNA modifying enzymes and necessitates unusual and likely novel catalytic strategies for methylation that are being revealed by biochemical and structural studies directed toward various family members. These efforts will no doubt yield more surprising discoveries in terms of tRNA modification enzymology.