Enhancing Actinide(III) over Lanthanide(III) Selectivity through Hard-by-Soft Donor Substitution: Exploitation and Implication of Near-Degeneracy-Driven Covalency.

Soft donor ligands often provide higher selectivity for actinides(III) over chemically similar lanthanides(III), e.g., in the AmIII-EuIII pair. Frequently, the origin of such selectivity is associated with an increased covalency in actinide-ligand bonding. However, the relationship between the degree of covalency and ion selectivity has yet to reach general consensus. Further, it is unclear whether the enhanced covalency leads to a thermodynamic stabilization of the complex or not. Using relativistic density functional theory, we have addressed these outstanding issues by analyzing the subtle change of metal-ligand interactions from a hard donor ligand to a mixed soft-hard one. The present comparative study on the structure of and binding in Am3+ and Eu3+ complexes with 3,4,3-LI(1,2-HOPO) (L) and its mixed-donor variant (LS) shows that the introduction of sulfur as a soft donor atom into the metal coordination sphere indeed infuses an Am3+ selectivity into the otherwise nonselective ligand L but also leads to a significant reduction of the metal-binding Gibbs free energies. Natural population analysis, charge decomposition analysis, and its extended version point to the critical role of ligand-to-metal charge transfer in the overall thermodynamic stability of the complexes. A detailed energy decomposition analysis combining the extended transition state with the natural orbitals chemical valence method reveals an enhancement of the covalency upon switching to the soft-hard donor ligand because of the different nature of the metal-ligand interaction. The ligand L predominantly binds the metal via π donation, whereas the ligand LS prefers σ donation. Molecular orbital and quantum theory of atoms in molecules analyses as well as a comparison to a simple model system show that the covalency occurs as a result of orbital mixing and is near-degeneracy-driven in nature. This enhanced covalency, however, fails to thermodynamically compensate for the loss of strong electrostatic interaction and thus does not lead to an additional stabilization of the metal-LS complexes.