A Comparative Evaluation of Root Surface Biomodification with Erbium-Doped Yttrium Aluminum Garnet Laser, Ethylenediaminetetraacetic Acid Gel, and Titanium Nitride Curette: In Vitro Scanning Electron Microscope and Profilometry Analyses.

Objective: This study aims to evaluate the in vitro effects of different biomodification treatment methods on extracted tooth/root surfaces in terms of biologically acceptable changes favoring better periodontal healing. Background data: The use of various agents for root surface biomodification (RSB), during periodontal procedures is of critical importance to increase the success of the treatments through healing. Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) is the most frequently used chemical RSB agent in periodontal clinical practice. Erbium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet (Er:YAG) lasers have well-known advantages on blood cell adhesion and fibrin network formation on root surfaces. Recently, novel titanium nitride (TIN) curettes are of great interest due to smoother surface changes obtained after their application. Materials and methods: Forty-four dentine specimens from extracted single-rooted teeth were randomly divided into four groups: Group 1: No treatment; Group 2: Er:YAG laser irradiation; Group 3: EDTA gel application; Group 4: TIN curette instrumentation. All specimen surfaces were wet polished before treatments. Before and after root surface roughness parameters of all specimens were assessed with a profilometer. Further, all scanning electron microscopy micrographs were analyzed and scored for root surface and smear layer morphology characteristics by two different blinded researchers. Results: There were no statistical differences between the initial roughness of all groups ( p  = 0.687). After treatments, EDTA gel group revealed an intact intertubular area, some smear debris on dentine surfaces, and partially occluded dentine tubules. Er:YAG laser created the highest roughness ( p  < 0.05) among all treatment groups with no smear layer and exhibited fully exposed dentine tubules and collagen fibrils. Surfaces instrumented with TIN curette were the smoothest ( p  < 0.05) and covered with a compact and thick smear layer. Conclusions: Within the limits of this study, Er:YAG laser-irradiated surfaces exhibited exposed collagen fibrils, and Er:YAG laser irradiation was found as the only method yielding the desired surface characteristics for better periodontal healing, where the fibrils are exposed in the absence of smear layer.