"I Went Into This Field to Empower Other People, and I Feel Like I Failed": Residents Experience Moral Distress Post- Dobbs .
Jema K TurkEmily ClaymoreNafeesa DawoodbhoyJody E SteinauerPublished in: Journal of graduate medical education (2024)
Background The 2022 Supreme Court ruling in Dobbs v Jackson Women's Health Organization nullified the constitutional right to abortion, which led to effective bans in at least 14 US states and placed obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYN) residents in dilemmas where they may have to withhold care, potentially causing moral distress-a health care workforce phenomenon less understood among resident physicians. Objective To identify and explore moral distress experienced by OB/GYN residents due to care restrictions post- Dobbs . Methods In 2023, we invited OB/GYN residents, identified by their program directors, training in states with restricted abortion access, to participate in one-on-one, semi-structured interviews via Zoom about their experiences caring for patients post- Dobbs . We used thematic analysis to analyze interview data. Results Twenty-one residents described their experiences of moral distress due to restrictions. We report on 3 themes in their accounts related to moral distress (and 4 subthemes): (1) challenges to their physician identity (inability to do the job, internalized distress, and reconsidering career choices); (2) participating in care that exacerbates inequities (and erodes patient trust); and (3) determination to advocate for and provide abortion care in the future. Conclusions OB/GYN residents grappled with moral distress and identified challenges from abortion restrictions.
Keyphrases
- healthcare
- quality improvement
- palliative care
- primary care
- mental health
- decision making
- public health
- affordable care act
- emergency department
- end stage renal disease
- pain management
- type diabetes
- newly diagnosed
- chronic kidney disease
- risk assessment
- skeletal muscle
- case report
- adipose tissue
- big data
- insulin resistance
- depressive symptoms
- prognostic factors
- pregnant women
- social support
- molecularly imprinted
- mass spectrometry
- solid phase extraction
- light emitting