COVID-19 Remote Consultation Services and Population in Health Inequity-Concentrating Territories: A Scoping Review.
Angélica Baptista SilvaSergio Ricardo Ferreira SindicoAna Carolina CarneiroSávio Mourão HenriqueArthur Gustavo FernandesJoyker Peçanha GomesThaysa Pereira MarinhoValcler Rangel FernandesPublished in: Telemedicine journal and e-health : the official journal of the American Telemedicine Association (2021)
Background: This review aimed to map initiatives for measuring the satisfaction of vulnerable populations with teleconsultation services offered by public and private health care providers in their territories, during the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic. Systematic studies on the opinions of people most affected by health inequities are limited. Therefore, we included evaluations of teleconsultation-based services offered to socioeconomically disadvantaged and clinically vulnerable populations globally, with a focus on surveillance, treatment, and prevention of COVID-19. Materials and Methods: This review includes analytical and descriptive observational studies primarily from MEDLINE, EMBASE, SCOPUS, and Web of Science databases, published after the World Health Organization received the first warnings about COVID-19 from Chinese authorities in December, 2019, until December 2020. The search strategy combined aspects of COVID-19, telemedicine, patient satisfaction, and key concepts of vulnerable populations. Results: We selected 33 studies for full-text reading and 10 for critical appraisal. Two categories emerged from the qualitative analysis: telehealth evaluation and services during COVID-19, and opinions of vulnerable populations. Television and social networks play a crucial role in providing information. Although teleconsultations are practical and cost effective for patients, the majority preferred receiving in-person treatment in primary care clinics. Conclusions: Listening to the opinions of vulnerable groups and their caregivers is critical both before and during adoption of COVID-19 control measures. Health managers need to monitor the health of and delivery of services to socioeconomically and clinically vulnerable people closely, to improve services, and provide care from a human rights perspective.
Keyphrases
- healthcare
- coronavirus disease
- primary care
- sars cov
- mental health
- public health
- health information
- respiratory syndrome coronavirus
- palliative care
- patient satisfaction
- end stage renal disease
- newly diagnosed
- genetic diversity
- systematic review
- randomized controlled trial
- quality improvement
- chronic kidney disease
- social media
- peritoneal dialysis
- emergency department
- big data
- mass spectrometry
- artificial intelligence
- cross sectional
- pain management
- patient reported outcomes
- smoking cessation
- general practice